![鲁迅辑校古籍考](https://wfqqreader-1252317822.image.myqcloud.com/cover/368/50868368/b_50868368.jpg)
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0005-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-h5w2y09HPc3ReskGx6wjYzMHYBwjtZjd-0-4801b07e4dfa8eee5b920ccfa888eafe)
图1-1 《故书杂集》手稿A。注意佚文末尾标署出处,作“同五十四”、“同上”、“《类聚》七”不一。(手稿书影编号的前一数字指对应章节,以下同。)
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0006-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-DPO9vaeibIdkVSYcoJRCAdCWtPpHO5st-0-979f3d4388573f38a0ad3e558c5b6bc9)
图1-2 《故书杂集》手稿A之《会稽先贤赞》。首条内容完全被次条涵盖,天头处所写《书钞》卷七九所引,又较次条更详。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0007-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-K42xyjLm2ISV8HlZpLK0Gvw5X2hg4d97-0-4496a7f6c6a320bbeac1174a1a055f07)
图1-3 《故书杂集》手稿B。鲁迅先从《御览》录出佚文,再以《寰宇记》《嘉泰会稽志》等书增补,墨色有明显差异,显然有一定时间间隔。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0008-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-h2G5ve0fW83atKwhWFmpuTB2deyVlPQB-0-f5f2822ac0ed0896d2596dd48947e3d6)
图1-4 《故书杂集》手稿B起首
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0008-2.jpg?sign=1739323541-zvVlowj3AhJ25672IVi5fWuuIPEaQDsx-0-419c01344e3d6533f4646466a91cf0b0)
图1-5 《故书杂集》手稿C起首
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0009-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-KOZ7ch6rwirTq3HFxXSuRvYDa6u26Nmy-0-9a3bff96ea0ed28c548a8a0cc28dacd4)
图1-6 《故书杂集》手稿D
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0010-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-8U9kplr7yh8eIFrtuD0GdNAmMEbLgZNP-0-c9520345c49192e9c2d4bd8bd61f1f3a)
图1-7 《故书杂集》手稿E
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0011-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-cOSqOlUCkGHApysMVEwFeljDetmQlsbC-0-fd796c1bb08a32749662c60c519ab1a8)
图1-8 《故书杂集》手稿F之《会稽典录》
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0012-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-w76KyjC7BXt68ECdYgFb9GxPEDSLJBRl-0-03807e26cd19cbe03336178bf2ebb58e)
图1-9 《说郛录要》,封面题“辛亥三月抄成”(1911年3月30日~4月28日)
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0013-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-0xDOsz5zJnCXgjKXo6QDChgzrZkjq1Ps-0-9507e92c532c1b3e534a036750f7ff23)
图1-10 《故书杂集》手稿G之《会稽先贤传》,第二则(第三行)佚文是周作人所写,其余是鲁迅笔迹。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0014-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-c4Vot9Q53kX23ZYXWEULhiJ52VUrKL0b-0-2e0856fbed5b75a10d727d6f479deda2)
图1-11 《故书杂集》手稿G之《会稽典录》虞国条,书口有周作人所题传主名,天头添入《乾道四明图经》《宝庆四明志》所引同一条佚文的面貌。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0015-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-7GfAgliwZ75KOu9RM2kN8dfz3YXGjkmA-0-fb2cf35ee0016f1092e43518cecfb7f2)
图1-12 《故书杂集》手稿H之《会稽典录》虞国条,佚文后案语据《书钞》《乾道四明图经》《宝庆四明志》所做考证,明显承袭自手稿G,可与图1-11对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0016-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-C9ssol1NB0qtPhGT2U1rUGMBxpAQwMRh-0-251028080d5d8dce7a7be5d52a2a8d95)
图1-13 《故书杂集》手稿H之《会稽典录》周昕条,佚文后节抄《三国志·吴志·孙静传》,作为“笺释性材料”,手稿G无此。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0017-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-iN13IItm7VvHYntrKWv4nkRJcsahw5T6-0-5370c2e305d4ef2ba4dc5d8a7379e511)
图1-14 《故书杂集》手稿I《会稽典录》周昕条,手稿H补写的抄自《文选》的材料,被作为案语随文写入;手稿H抄录的《三国志·孙静传》材料,亦被保留,可与图1-13对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0018-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-KLBikzDfc4eobX7vv8rPypIYW73ZKrRC-0-dcdb9a9f1bef5b170b66fabf83745b40)
图1-15 《故书杂集》刻本,经鲁迅校改。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0019-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-2pJ4deZazlOfz8u15V6hPWsZiy6wEUib-0-703f674e7f4457e9fb5eca3a00f54af8)
图2-1 谢承书手稿A。此叶前三行是周作人笔迹,其下为鲁迅笔迹。各条佚文加圈及顿号,意指汪本已辑录此条。第二条“戴就”辑自《御览》卷三七〇,朱笔校字(周作人笔迹)是据“第二出处”《御览》卷四二〇校出。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0020-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-luGQ4ZIWeZaGTxSgX0Hh2pR2Kq58kVVV-0-caf00e5ab738fe93aa249902a7bf124c)
图2-2 谢承书手稿B,戴就条标题加圈,表示此条见于手稿A,可与图2-1对看。卷中多有点画及校字,以标识不同出处所引的同一佚文的差异。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0021-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-eUFrnefJgjM6iSRSJ6YNwlqvkpi25sr5-0-3fe62dfc91ee831137379d0c5dd4edd8)
图2-3 谢承书手稿C卷四,巴祗条与董宣条间补入王阜条,巴祗条案语也有删改。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0022-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-vsZSiinoyku8VddvRVJmer5k2cCUSsuJ-0-4ec1223c24b1af30468e3ef269b5b788)
图2-4 谢承书手稿C目录,就王阜条的补入,做了相应调整。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0023-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-NNWmxTPLBU9NPRfNW2tvKW8PKMd9EZJ6-0-84a12a0168d0498cfad622cbb249a274)
图2-5 谢承书手稿D《谢承后汉书序》
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0024-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-8NHSyaCDK9O6qID6OyzYxbyYeEwJlWtU-0-c54b43d98007dcfd461549992a47f293)
图2-6 谢承书手稿E《谢承后汉书考》
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0025-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-gzzNwaczLY26jTKhXwr8K4Medu2VfZRO-0-5ae8a84f77080654a58083896955b2da)
图3-1 谢沈书手稿A
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0026-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-qzjKq0vTh7zcr0XmAsPnBSnw58WAPls7-0-892766c40612c1d009d8d89a234e48d4)
图3-2 谢沈书手稿B
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0027-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-xDXd9kvDhfeViE3sKDZ8hQrl7Ufc6yhJ-0-276d36ba82fe20facd11ba1410d1a60a)
图4-1 虞预书手稿A。卢钦条天头处鲁迅标记《书钞》卷五九所引的文本面貌,又从《三国志》裴注补辑黄本失收的一则佚文。各佚文末尾所标辑录出处加圈,表示已据原书核验。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0028-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-kfKAsm9PydLi6fqVRiFyGuYTp9SCf7kf-0-f4845095427cad26e2c9f2690eba81e0)
图4-2 虞预书手稿B。卢钦条已按手稿A的标记改订,可与图4-1对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0029-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-kDIdXV2aPbeymkr1wunsI3P38r2gU4PE-0-2833b896d5b877c666f3d66ddccdaa93)
图附-1 针对《谢氏后汉书补逸》何元锡藏本所作的《丁志》初稿,后被人移至丁氏传抄本(南图112363)。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0030-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-jPUTerqWNQooXBmotsTCXECkQ6Ycj9Hu-0-4fcd291138b8962795cc8adcbbbf688f)
图附-2 何元锡旧藏清抄本《谢氏后汉书补逸》,现藏浙江图书馆。《丁志》提及的何元锡的两方藏印,及八千卷楼的“钱塘丁氏藏书”俱见本叶。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0031-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-8Q5CMJXMIFKSSXsUz1Q6p6Bs3m1sdRSi-0-78eadfcc0c3f333107728d87cbf34f81)
图5-1 《嵇康集》手稿A
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0032-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-4HzBywkLqgHketdMogbnnxRzF592SJyf-0-d0497f5b67772a6e9f44d56f997d2175)
图5-2 《嵇康集》手稿A
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0033-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-vSyC6TAxu7Ns3s93PNCxgHWujtnDtVqW-0-8bacec566b58038344d58a8f186f1f28)
图5-3 《嵇康集》手稿B中标注诸本异文的不同形式
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0034-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-Rq2PBu1MbrL8RziK7lpMSrcDTU2wphOC-0-e77e5ce758ed1bcac648a90b0d3738bd)
图5-4 《嵇康集》手稿B
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0035-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-qrz1o21cMqglWZiP3Ouv7fkMWd5sgvbu-0-582400b305cd7012a57cacf72c8375c0)
图9-1 南京图书馆藏《沈下贤文集》影抄小草斋本,朱笔校字是其独有。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0035-2.jpg?sign=1739323541-LgAut21PqXV3IQ4w5h8Y1UB1pKJM4hwC-0-dd4e7f958b49d5facb728ab657060d73)
图9-2 复旦大学图书馆藏《沈下贤文集》小草斋抄本
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0036-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-IteHUPzOIEkIKGakaxOyujBdzac9eOUa-0-1761c4666613facfb39724c4843fc13a)
图9-3 《沈下贤文集》手稿A。鲁迅依影抄本校字面貌抄录,可与图9-1、图9-2对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0037-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-mIgR8clGdhRBDDhSZMsQEMooWlm2XWol-0-ec2b75f9290226ca3bf58ddf914d1e4f)
图9-4 《沈下贤文集》手稿A。“启”(第二行)、“珚泗”(第七行)、“夜”、“檀”(第八行)等字加圈。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0038-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-uBhTtkTI8e5CSrZWOUoKJZ0kEAvEpAFe-0-0c3bf857a6eaec3dab4bb6985e51f07c)
图9-5 《沈下贤文集》手稿B。与图9-4对看可知,手稿A有异文处,手稿B皆不取加圈之字。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0039-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-5Ot8aPvFo65ZVg9B2a5dCw2dgZPQSJ1r-0-5da061454697229e44394b363d2ceef0)
图11-1 《文士传》手稿B。刘桢条第4则与第5则,第4则案语明显是一气写成,顺承连接,没有后续插补的情况。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0040-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-JSHh0LlWxJkjz6oovIE2OUT4KCIPiHCM-0-78a9dfaa7de1551eae9b3d723c79da02)
图11-2 《文士传》手稿C
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0041-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-IiGKpT5xnWcNDyP93bXd5Ho4gmPWkhEI-0-2edd833e2634bd7d610343905d4703ea)
图12-1 《众家文章记录》手稿A挚虞《文章志》缪袭条,体现了手稿B从《文选》注辑出的内容,不过案语“《文选》缪熙伯《挽歌诗》注引首四字”明显是后添加的。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0042-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-C81G6pMcW7DfSYGarMLNQ20VzwqJzh9k-0-bfa83a494b567b112fe49cab9ba2dad5)
图12-2 《众家文章记录》手稿B。此枚断片上有3则佚文。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0042-2.jpg?sign=1739323541-ccHtltRrolxOk06gWy7ksJrukbcd1K6T-0-78c9e3c574432f76353ec0aa48ca49d2)
图12-3 《众家文章记录》手稿B繁钦条
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0043-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-zNyoXvYillGgMmTqOF7Qym8f7tGUVJW6-0-c4de8f7e7816f160a2e9b655d152e772)
图13-1 《岭表录异》手稿A。注意天头处据《御览》的校语与据《埤雅》的校语的书写位置关系。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0044-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-kLnCVz7YYVETVHar4FClmJUxliVdJreL-0-4e0bbefcb34a70d7d49ab87a8c5fece5)
图13-2 《岭表录异》手稿B。行间校字是以佚文“第二出处”校“第一出处”的结果。如此叶第二条,行间校字是表示《舆地纪胜》卷一〇五的引文面貌。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0045-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-DVRfF9nX68fGrzJWeJ4XlK5mUF8EN8a8-0-698700303718eb08702abbc7d8d81388)
图13-3 《岭表录异》手稿G。天头处记录《离骚草木疏》《猗觉寮杂记》《通鉴》引文面貌,鲁迅翻检此三书显然是在手稿G写成后。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0046-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-vHDlij69rq97ib83lkxsxmxhGbvO21YJ-0-d8cfa08ab1fc9881d84d6a0375281c55)
图13-4 《岭表录异》手稿F。前三行是鲁迅所写,第四行起是周作人所写,后半叶首行起又是鲁迅笔迹。各条上加点,指已与手稿A(武英殿本)对勘。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0047-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-SqwflUsPL8WL1AP8dp1RP4eXknEQbR6A-0-858e5495663272831477e653faa1f9ed)
图14-1 明抄本《说郛》卷三〇《云谷杂记》(国图A00487)
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0048-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-XUPrU3Nn4ZCp57UsTCfqusOUDHxnEDLA-0-55d41fd0ce8bdf049fd5a94bf3226da8)
图14-2 《云谷杂记》手稿A
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0049-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-1MhNYAY6UWn2mFXAc0dgBmsgFl8fjT9z-0-d753cbf50339fa03ef10fb29fc40e91a)
图16-1 《范子计然》手稿A补遗,此部分专录茆本所无的佚文。朱笔所写的两条佚文是周作人笔迹,其余是鲁迅所写。周作人录出这两条佚文后,鲁迅增补了其他出处并标记异文。可见手稿A递次增补的层次。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0050-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-vpq0JBer781t2TBUX0SXlK2ixcu46kas-0-cd787a2d8e4ac74026a794b5eab7117e)
图16-2 《范子计然》手稿A。首行朱笔“《书钞》百四十七”云云是鲁迅所写,天头处朱笔“御览连下”是周作人所写;第六行墨笔所补出处及异文情况“《事类赋》二十五注”云云,茆本所无,是鲁迅所写。第七条行间“《要术》引此句,武作五”及天头处墨笔,也是鲁迅所写。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0051-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-1HuutyH9HdsMi9DNcMcIchuAcjmnjvZt-0-f72f1b73735ccdc84a42ae1e723c4c03)
图16-3 《范子计然》手稿D。手稿A的校改增补,在此均做了对应处理,可与图16-2对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0052-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-CaGn5Sr4Jzr6tsQTTHMarURFXxotAd5y-0-7ea60af684cb697d61f8b9254597a8a1)
图16-4 《范子计然》手稿A。注意首条行间的校字,与周广业《意林注》有对应关系。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0053-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-S1IlpfgCJGbaVyUMClhIf0GhQQbASTx4-0-4058b115337709bd9dcba5a8da831634)
图16-5 《范子计然》手稿C。此件是周作人抄录的周广业《意林注》中的《范子计然》部分。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0054-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-936EldaQmqdT9eJQV4e7EoV0BVfkHg8P-0-27e71b0712bffd973524c28e824a7534)
图16-6 《范子计然》手稿B,鲁迅抄录的马国翰辑本序。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0055-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-JTU9WBVQF2dT8mRqXQP4efl7kDx448Dv-0-b988f146917e0d44ca7d18f5001b4832)
图16-7 《魏子》手稿A。“居危殆之国”条天头处的朱笔增补是周作人所写,一旁的墨笔增补是鲁迅所写,末行案语后的朱笔是鲁迅所写。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0056-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-2ds0lSW4KpUFRGpgOtmcd5tvA6GAR6Yg-0-d01178cb57cb3e227453905d37939cca)
图16-8 《魏子》手稿C。“居危殆之国”条根据手稿A的增补而改动,可与图16-7对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0057-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-QAc4HBz2QuuNf9g6GCmz0e6Oh7VtwP46-0-d07d3e2416e1384138a57302f1fd9ee4)
图16-9 《任子》手稿A前半部分。正文第五行“木气人”条、末行“道德之怀民”条加“¬”,这两条《意林》亦引。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0058-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-nnlUJBmI3lhMQOFnp3CMkPszhvvj4W38-0-602766a09bce68b9b6d446967f2c6f28)
图16-10 《任子》手稿B。此件是周作人抄写,但首行“道德之怀民”条下“《御览》四百三”、末行“木气人”条下“二十六”是鲁迅所加,这是比勘手稿A后所为,可与手稿A对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0059-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-gLuKAFAafbieNEzUTfXSY14fyPtYT64k-0-6ab4f17a1946b13785703b937481a070)
图16-11 《志林》手稿A。天头处补“横江将军鲁肃卒”条,马本失辑。“古人铸刀”的出处“《御览》卷三百四十五”旁红笔加点,意指核验了《御览》所引原文,可与图16-12对看。
![](https://epubservercos.yuewen.com/FFC48B/29979865903593706/epubprivate/OEBPS/Images/0060-1.jpg?sign=1739323541-WtuZwwBN3TtWNPcRwZ11SCjTxB4yaK6u-0-69a0477ad876d15acebb2e2c7c3676fb)
图16-12 《志林》手稿B。注意此叶上的“古人铸刀”条。